Log in

20 July 2007 @ 11:34 am
So, as only silverseaicons and loper42 entered the challenge, this is now the final challenge

- Vote for one [1] icon you think is the worst.
- Vote according to the quality of the icons, NOT the Icons you like the LEAST, or the styles you don't favor. Please give a specific reason as to why you think it is the worst, such as: 'the icon is over sharpened,' or 'bad choice of text'. Please try to be unbiased with your vote and try to be discriptive! please when you comment, try not to use the word 'I' [example: "I didn't like..."]
- Also vote for one favorite icon, you don't have to give a reason, all though we would love it if you do. Please remember to vote for a favorite!
- Comments will be screened
- Voting will end: July 24th at 12 am, CST.

Least Favorite or Worst
054 - The icons looks too washed out and the tiny tex doesn't fit

085 - The colouring of the icon is very nice and the cropping is stunnig

1. 2.

A question: Do you think we should keep this going for now? Not many people is interested, they drop out, and it may be due to Will not doing many things at the moment... so what do you think? Another round, or maybe a hiatus for now?
Charmanderpokecharm on July 20th, 2007 05:50 pm (UTC)
good lord, what happened to this lims? I swear there were more people in this. Why would we do one fav and one lesser - why don't we just vote for one we like since this is the final voting?
Saraisari1490 on July 21st, 2007 03:06 am (UTC)
Yes, I know.
We vote for "least favorite" because some pleople might want to know why others didn't liked their icons, and use it for improving their skills